bringbackaether

not only has it been unfinished for 10 years, almost nothing interesting has happened in the meantime. it's not charming or nostalgic, it's clunky and old and boring.

they're always working on something, but it just seems to be racing to adapt their dinosaur codebase to newer versions of minecraft. A new mod definitely needs to step in and take the "fantasy dimension mod with progression" role.

This mod is an older mod that has always been cool, but has had various issues, mainly balancing. But the dev has been active and continues to make serious improvements, it's a staple mod for any adventure pack imo.

It's alright. I think many LunaPixel modpacks get an unreasonable amount of hate and it's become trendy to shit talk them, and this pack is probably the reason.

It's incredibly popular but doesn't really do all that much - personally, I don't see why you would play this pack, but at least it seems fairly stable and polished if what you want is "vanilla with some small QoL changes."

If you wanted to play a more "Minecraft with lots of extras," I think you would be better off playing something like AOF, Prominence, or ATM.

Playing this just makes me happy. The custom assets are great, it's a really enjoyable idea overall, and the pack seems well polished. The dev is very active and responsive as well from what I've seen.

I didn't really enjoy this pack, and I think it's extremely overrated and skewed by people who have a strange obsession for reading meticulously through thousands of quest descriptions and consider that to be gameplay. But if that's you, it does seem to be pretty polished.

Also, probably mostly because it's on an older version and has no resource pack, it's really ugly

Doesn't do anything unique, all the reviews on here were clearly left by the modpack dev's friends or alt accounts.

It seems to be decently polished, but its "custom mods" are just worse alternatives to more popular mods, and there's nothing else really engaging here.